Case Studies

 

John Menzies Headquarters, Edinburgh

 

Notable Features
bullet Precast coffered slab units
(steel formworks)
bullet Steel shutters for in-situ edge beams
bullet Steel structure for atrium
bullet Raised floor system
Basic Information
Location :
Edinburgh Part, Edinburgh, UK
Building Type :
Office
Contract Period :

08/1994 - 09/1995

Client :
John Menzies (UK)
Project Manager :
Buro Four Project Services
Architect :
Bennetts Associates Architects
Structural Engineer :
Curtins Consulting
M&E Services Engineer :

Blyth & Blyth Ltd.

Quantity Surveyor :
Banks Wood & Partners
Liaison Architect :
Campbell & Arnott Ltd.
Landscape Architect :
Ian White Associates
Acoustic Consultants :
Arup Acoustics
Masterplan Architect :
Richard Meier & Partners
Management Contractor :
Bovis Scotland
.
Overview
 
 
 
The building issues considered were flexibility, good communications and environmental conditions. Within the resulting workplace, which is generally composed of 12m wide floor-plates, the three-storey building adopts a compact quadrangle form, with circulation balconies around the inner perimeter and a partly glazed roof covering the central space.
 
 
Structures
 
 
Flexibility consideration resulted in a 12m clear floor span from the external building perimeter to the perimeter of the atrium.
 
Sources
 
bullet www.ajspecification.com
bullet The Architects’ Journal, 30 November 1995, pp29-39.
 
   
Precast Coffered Slab Units
Reduction in the on-site program period was possible with a hybrid in-situ concrete frame with precast coffered slab units. The coffered slab units, each weighing 11 tones, were manufactured off-site using steel moulds. The sequence of frame construction was to erect the 400mm diameter columns first, then place the 12m long precast coffer units on temporary supports. It was followed by the casting of the in-situ perimeter ring beam and structural topping in one operation, to tie the precast elements together.
Steel Shutters for In-situ Edge Beams
 
The use of purpose-made steel shutters, both for on-site for in-situ edge beams, and off-site for the coffer units, enhanced the quality of finish and speed of construction.
Roof Steel Structure for the Atrium

The roof steelwork over the atrium comprises slender steel trusses at 6m centers spanning the 12m width of the atrium. The top and bottom chords are formed from back-to-back steel channel sections with 32mm diameter tie rods forming the internal bracing.

Cost Analysis
The cost analysis is based on post-tender resolution costs, which would most accurately represent an analysis of tender under a traditional form of contract. The overall figure of £1140/m2 (low energy design), including fit-out, is well within the range of costs for similar buildings.
Cost Summary
 

Low-Waste Buildings Technologies & Practices
Home